Article

C.I. Renews Property Policy for Industrial Client

9/2/2025

C.I. Renews $1m GWP Industrial Client

This independent distributor specializing in industrial and contractor supplies, headquartered in Illinois is recognized for its broad inventory, expert knowledge and reliable local service. With 40+ years of experience, over $260m in total insured values, and loss free claims experience for their property exposures, they have retained a significant amount of underwriting profit within their wholly owned captive insurance company.

Captive Insurance Solution Provided

  • Policy Structure: C.I. structured and placed a primary $5 million per occurrence / $5 million aggregate property policy.
  • Captive Retention: Captive retained 100% of the risk and underwriting profit associated with this layer.
  • Carrier Paper: The policy was issued on A+ AM Best, XV Admitted Paper, ensuring lender acceptance and compliance with financing requirements.
  • Deductible Structure: Deductibles were set at levels acceptable to lenders, balancing risk retention with financial prudence.
  • Premium Flow: Approximately $700k in gross written premium (GWP) is retained by the captive annually, representing a significant portion of the total premium and maximizing retention of underwriting profit.

Key Features and Strategic Benefits

1. Enhanced Control and Customization

  • The captive reinsures the fronting carrier, allowing the company to participate directly in claims management, and risk mitigation strategies tailored to their unique portfolio and loss history.
  • By using a captive, the insured has the flexibility to adjust coverage terms and risk appetite as their business evolves, rather than being limited by rigid commercial market offerings.

2. Financial Impact

  • Captive retention of ~$75% annually enables the captive to keep 100% of underwriting profit on the reinsured portion, directly reducing their net total cost of risk.
  • Surplus generated in the captive can be invested over time, providing an additional income stream and supporting long-term financial resilience.

3. Lender and Regulatory Compliance

  • Policies are issued on the highest rated admitted paper, ensuring compliance with lender requirements and facilitating continued access to project financing.
  • The use of a fronting carrier ensures regulatory compliance across jurisdictions and allows the captive to issue certificates of insurance as required by third parties.

4. Risk Management and Claims Control

  • This captive structure empowers the company to influence claims handling, including the ability to select counsel and manage litigation, which can lead to lower claim costs and improved outcomes.
  • The captive’s direct involvement in risk management encourages a proactive approach to loss prevention and safety, further reducing claims frequency and severity.

5. Long-Term Strategic Advantages

  • As the captive accumulates surplus from profitable underwriting years, the captive can distribute dividends back to ownership, reinvest in business operations, or expand coverage to additional lines as their needs grow. C.I.’s program allows for surplus to be distributed 90-120 days after the expiration of the policy period.
  • The captive structure provides a buffer against insurance market volatility, reducing exposure to sudden premium increases or coverage restrictions in the commercial market.

Feature

Details

Policy Limit

$5 million per occurrence / $5 million aggregate

Captive Retention

100%

Carrier Paper

A+ AM Best, XV surplus lines

Captive Premium Retention

75% GWP

Lender Acceptance

Yes, with compliant deductible structure

Key Benefits

Underwriting profit retention, claims control, investment income, surplus growth

Regulatory Compliance

Achieved via fronting carrier and surplus lines paper

Strategic Impact

Lower total cost of risk, improved risk management, financial resilience

By partnering with Captives Insure, this client successfully implemented a captive insurance solution that delivers superior control, transparency, and financial benefit compared to traditional insurance. The program not only meets lender and regulatory requirements but also positions them to maximize underwriting profit, invest surplus, and strengthen long-term business resilience.

Start Building