Every well-run captive has a captive manager at its center. It is one of the most important relationships in the structure and, for organizations new to the concept, one of the least understood. The manager is neither the owner nor the insurer; it is the professional firm that keeps the captive operating, compliant, and financially sound year after year. Understanding what the captive manager does — and, just as importantly, what it does not do — is essential to understanding how a captive program actually functions
Ask most executives what their insurance costs, and they will point to the premium. It is the number on the invoice, the figure in the budget, the line item finance reviews at renewal. But premium is only one component of a broader and more revealing measure: the total cost of risk. Organizations that manage to premium alone are optimizing a single variable while ignoring the system it sits within — and in doing so, they often overlook the largest opportunities to reduce what risk actually costs them
Every risk a captive considers writing sits somewhere on a spectrum defined by two variables: how often losses occur, and how large they are when they do. Frequency risk describes exposures that produce many small, predictable claims. Severity risk describes exposures that produce few claims, but potentially catastrophic ones. Understanding where a given line falls on this spectrum is the starting point for structuring any captive program — and it dictates almost everything about how that program should be capitalized, reserved, and reinsured.
The captive conversation almost always begins the same way: an organization is frustrated with the commercial market. Rates have climbed for several renewals in a row, terms have narrowed, and the premium check no longer feels connected to the company's own loss experience. This inevitably drives the insured to question if they should just insure the risks themselves
A regional habitational property manager operating a multifamily portfolio across the five boroughs of New York City — with additional exposures in Westchester County and northern New Jersey — already owned and operated its own captive insurance company. The captive allowed the business to retain its own premium and underwriting result rather than surrender them to the commercial market. What it lacked was the one thing its lenders and contractual counterparties insisted on: coverage issued on AM Best-rated paper
Captives Insure is heading to Burlington, Vermont for the Vermont Captive Insurance Association (VCIA) Annual Conference — the largest and longest-running educational event in the captive insurance industry.
The feature appears in Captive Insurance Times' July 2026 edition, which brings together reporting, interviews, and analysis from across the captive and reinsurance community. The full issue is available on the publication's website
SUBMIT A RISK